Hans Halvorson Physics, Logic, Philosophy

Danish Philosophical Texts

Transcriptions and English translations of Danish philosophical works, primarily from the nineteenth century. All source texts are in the public domain; scans are drawn from the Royal Danish Library. LaTeX sources and PDF files are on GitHub. For scholarly commentary on each text, see the notes page.

Status: completein progressskeletonto docoming soon

F.C. Sibbern

Frederik Christian Sibbern, professor of philosophy at Copenhagen 1813–1870. Close friend of Poul Martin Møller; Kierkegaard attended his lectures. A transitional figure who resisted the Hegelian campaign of the 1830s and anticipated several of Kierkegaard's central arguments.

Bemærkninger og Undersøgelser, fornemmelig betreffende Hegels Philosophie
1838. C.A. Reitzel, Copenhagen
Complete workto do
Om Erkjendelse og Granskning
Epistemological work; date to be confirmed.
Complete workto do
Menneskets aandelige Natur og Væsen
1819. Copenhagen
Complete workto do

Poul Martin Møller

Poet, philosopher, and Professor of Philosophy at Copenhagen 1831–1838. The most important philosophical figure in the generation immediately preceding Kierkegaard; the Concept of Anxiety is dedicated to his memory.

Tanker over Muligheden af Beviser for Menneskets Udødelighed
1837. Maanedsskrift for Litteratur 17 (1837), pp. 1–72 and 422–453
Complete essay (pp. 168–253)TranscriptionScanTranslation (Stewart 2022)in progress
En Dansk Students Eventyr
1824 / 1843. Efterladte Skrifter, bd. 3, ed. F.C. Olsen, C.A. Reitzel
Written c. 1824; published posthumously 1843. Selections.
Licentiaten (the Licentiate episode)TranscriptionTranslationcomplete
Remainder of novellaWikisourceto do
Strøtanker
1843. Efterladte Skrifter, bd. 3, ed. F.C. Olsen, C.A. Reitzel
Selections.
Problemet »Udødelighed«to do
Eksistentialismeto do
Dybdepsykologito do
Hvad er Philosophie?
1843. Efterladte Skrifter, bd. 3, ed. F.C. Olsen, C.A. Reitzel
Indledning (pp. 115–118, Madsen edition)Transcriptionin progress
Remainder of lecture courseto do
Qvindelighed
1843. Efterladte Skrifter, bd. 3, ed. F.C. Olsen, C.A. Reitzel
Complete essayTranscriptionto do

Søren Kierkegaard

The essential upstream figure for the entire Nielsen–Brøchner–Høffding debate. This collection includes only passages most directly relevant to that debate; complete texts are available through the Royal Danish Library and in the Princeton University Press Kierkegaard's Writings series.

Concluding Unscientific Postscript (1846), excerpt on immortality
1846. Princeton University Press (Hong & Hong trans.)
Pages 153–158. Translated by David F. Swenson and Walter Lowrie.
pp. 153–158Translationcomplete

Rasmus Nielsen

Professor of philosophy at Copenhagen 1841–1884. Developed the central position of the mid-century debate: that faith and knowledge spring from absolutely heterogeneous principles. Target of both Brøchner's philosophical critique and Brandes's cultural polemic.

Mag. S. Kierkegaards "Johannes Climacus" og Dr. H. Martensens "Christelige Dogmatik"
1849. C.A. Reitzel, Copenhagen
Complete workto do
Om Theologiens Naturbegreb, med særligt Hensyn til Malebranche
1855. Det Schultziske Officin (Universitetsprogram)
Complete workTranscriptionTranslationskeleton
Philosophie og Mathematik
1857. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Selectionsto do
Mathematik og Dialektik
1859. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Selectionsto do
Grundideernes Logik, vols. I–II
1864–1866. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Selections (vol. I, §§ on the Objektiveringslov)KB Scanto do
Om den Gode Vilje som Magt i Videnskaben
1867. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Complete workto do
Logik og Psychologie
1867. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Lecture course for the university year 1867–68.
I. Subjectiv Logik i Omrids (pp. 1–263)Transcriptionskeleton
II. Psychologie (pp. 264–277)Transcriptionskeleton
III. Psychologie og Biologie (pp. 277–477)Transcriptionskeleton
Om Hindringer og Betingelser for det aandelige Liv i Nutiden
1868. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
SelectionsKB ScanTranscriptionskeleton
Religionsphilosophie
1869. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Introduction (§§ 1–2)TranscriptionTranslationin progress
§§ 3 onwardto do
Ide og Virkelighed
1869. For Ide og Virkelighed 1(1): 1–39
Complete essay (pp. 1–39)Journalto do
Et Synspunkt for Darwinismen
1873. For Ide og Virkelighed 8(1): 449–459
Complete articleTranscriptionTranslationcomplete
Natur og Aand
1873. J.H. Schubothe, Copenhagen
Selections (689 pp. total)KB Scanto do
Om Betingelserne for en kraftig Villie
1874. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Complete workto do
Gamle og nye Profeter: Seks Forelæsninger
1878. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Selectionsto do
Philosophiske Grundproblemer
1879. Universitetets Festskrift, Copenhagen
Complete work (77 pp.)Transcriptionskeleton
Almindelig Videnskabslære i Grundtræk
1880. Gyldendalske Boghandel, Copenhagen
Complete work (§§ 1–26, 281 pp.)TranscriptionTranslationcomplete
Om det oprindelige Forhold mellem Religion og Videnskab
1881. Schultz, Copenhagen
University festival address, 8 April 1881.
Section ITranscriptionTranslationcomplete
Sections II–IVto do
Forelæsninger over »Philosophisk Propædeutik« (1862), Darwin excerpt
1862. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Pages 326–328: the earliest philosophical engagement with Darwin in the Danish tradition.
Darwin excerpt (pp. 326–328)TranscriptionTranslationcomplete

Hans Brøchner

Professor of philosophy at Copenhagen 1857–1875. Post-Hegelian, moved toward a naturalistic humanism under the influence of Feuerbach and Strauss. His critical engagement with Kierkegaard and Nielsen makes him a crucial third voice; Høffding credited Brøchner's lectures as the direct cause of his own conversion away from Nielsen's position.

Om Søren Kierkegaards Virksomhed som religieus Forfatter
1855. Fædrelandet, 1 December 1855
Published anonymously under the mark "-r".
Complete articleto do
Benedict Spinoza. En Monographie
1857. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Complete workto do
Problemet om Tro og Viden
1868. Philipsen, Copenhagen
Complete work (226 pp.)TranscriptionTranslationKB Scanin progress
Et Svar til Professor R. Nielsen
1868. Philipsen, Copenhagen
Complete workto do
Georg Brandes, Levned vol. I (1905), pp. 129–132
1905. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Primary source for Brøchner's personality and influence.
Excerpt (pp. 129–132)TranscriptionTranslationcomplete
Om det Religiøse i dets Enhed med det Humane
1869. Philipsen, Copenhagen
Complete workKB Scanto do
Bidrag til Opfattelsen af Philosophiens historiske Udvikling
1869. Philipsen, Copenhagen
Complete workto do
Erindringer om Søren Kierkegaard
1877. Det nittende Aarhundrede; book form ed. Steen Johansen, 1953
Written 1871–72; published posthumously 1877.
Complete workto do

Georg Brandes

Critic and intellectual, later principal organizer of the Modern Breakthrough. As a young philosophy student under Sibbern and Nielsen, he wrote his first major work as a direct attack on Nielsen's dualism.

Dualismen i vor nyeste Philosophie
1866. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Complete work (76 pp.)KB Scanto do
Levned, Bind I (1905), selected passages
1905. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Passages on Brøchner and Nielsen. Source: georgbrandes.dk.
Selected passagesTranscriptionin progress
Samlede Skrifter, Trettende Bind
1899. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
Gathers Nielsen controversy writings. OCR text at Project Runeberg.
Striden om Tro og Viden (pp. 1–42)to do
Dualismen i vor nyeste Filosofi (pp. 43–84)to do
Om den gode Vilje som Magt i Videnskaben (pp. 85–92)to do
Nielsen og Grundtvig (pp. 93–97)to do
R. Nielsens Lære om Tro og Viden (pp. 106–109)to do

Harald Høffding

Nielsen's student and eventual successor as the dominant figure in Danish philosophy. His intellectual development is the key to the whole debate: in 1866 he explicitly defended Nielsen's position, then within a year — under Brøchner's influence — changed his mind completely, spending the next three decades working out what that conversion implied.

Studentnoter fra Rasmus Nielsens kursus om Grundideernes Logik
c. 1864–1866. Manuscript
Høffding's handwritten notes from Nielsen's lectures on Grundideernes Logik.
Complete manuscriptcoming soon
Philosophie og Theologie: en historisk-kritisk Afhandling
1866. Copenhagen
Complete work (46 pp.)KB Scanto do
Filosofien og Darwinismen
1874. For Ide og Virkelighed
Complete articleTranscriptionTranslationcomplete
Psykologi i Omrids paa Grundlag af Erfaring
1882. Philipsen, Copenhagen (2nd ed. 1885)
English translation: Outlines of Psychology (1891).
Complete work (421 pp.)TranscriptionTranslationin progress
Realisme i Videnskab og Tro
1882 / 1884. In Mindre Arbejder (1899)
Delivered as lecture 2 September 1882; published revised 1884.
Forholdet mellem Tro og Viden i dets historiske Udvikling
1885. In Mindre Arbejder (1899)
Complete essayTranscriptionTranslationWikisourcein progress
Søren Kierkegaard som Filosof
1892. P.G. Philipsens Forlag, Copenhagen
Chapter IV.A: Erkendelsesteori (pp. 58–70)TranscriptionTranslationin progress
Kontinuiteten i Kants filosofiske Udviklingsgang
1893. Det Kongelige Danske Videnskabernes Selskabs Skrifter, 6. Række, Historisk og Filosofisk Afdeling, 4(2)
Complete articleTranscriptionTranslationHathiTrustcomplete
Religionsfilosofi
1901. Gyldendal, Copenhagen
English translation: The Philosophy of Religion (1906).
Complete workTranscriptionTranslationKB Scanin progress
Filosofiske Problemer
1902. Copenhagen
English version: The Problems of Philosophy (1905), preface by William James.
Selectionsto do
Vort Hjem
1903. Introduction to Emma Gad, Vort Hjem
Complete essayTranscriptionTranslationin progress
Om Begrebet Analogi og dets filosofiske Betydning
1905. In Mindre Arbejder II
Published simultaneously in English in Mind (1905).
Complete essayto do
Den menneskelige Tanke, dens Former og dens Opgaver
1910. Copenhagen
Selections (epistemological chapters)Runebergto do
Personlighedsprincippet i Filosofien
1911. Det Kongelige Danske Videnskabernes Selskab, 2013 (Danish trans.)
Six lectures, Helsingfors spring 1911. First published in Swedish; Danish trans. Mogens Blegvad.
Complete work (Danish trans., 67 pp.)PDFto do
Totalitet som Kategori: en erkendelsesteoretisk Undersøgelse
1917. Copenhagen
Complete workto do
Relation som Kategori: en erkendelsesteoretisk Undersøgelse
1921. Bianco Lunos Bogtrykkeri, Copenhagen
Published in Filosofiske Meddelelser I, 3. Contains engagement with Einstein's relativity.
§3b: Den nye Relativitetsteori (pp. 72–77)TranscriptionTranslationin progress
Remainder of workto do
Relation som Kategori (1921), Høffding's annotated copy
1921. Manuscript marginalia
Marginaliacoming soon
Pascal et Kierkegaard
1923. Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale 30(2): 221–246
Written in French. Systematic comparison in four parts.
Complete article (26 pp.)JSTORto do
Begrebet Analogi
1923. Copenhagen
Complete workto do
Erkendelsesteori og Livsopfattelse
1925. Det Kongelige Danske Videnskabernes Selskab, Copenhagen
Complete work (7 chapters)TranslationDanish (Royal Academy)complete
Erindringer
1928. Gyldendalske Boghandel, Copenhagen
Autobiography, published in his 85th year.
II. 1861–1874 (pp. 38–93)Runebergto do
IV. 1883–1894 (pp. 121–174)Runebergto do
V. 1894–1904 (pp. 175–223)Runebergto do
VI. 1904–1914 (pp. 224–265)Runebergto do
Brevveksling med Niels Bohr
Manuscript correspondence
Complete correspondencecoming soon
Brevveksling med Émile Meyerson
Manuscript correspondence
Location of manuscripts to be established.
Complete correspondenceplaceholder